The appointment of Aden Duale as the new Cabinet Secretary for Health has sparked a wave of opposition, with the Kenya Medical Practitioners, Pharmacists and Dentists Union (KMPDU) leading the charge. Renowned lawyer Nelson Havi has joined the outcry, questioning Duale’s suitability for the role and urging for merit-based appointments in all ministries.

In a statement on Monday, March 31, Havi criticized Duale’s appointment, arguing that Kenya boasts numerous professionals better equipped to handle the Health Ministry’s demands.

Havi’s stance aligns with KMPDU’s argument that political appointees without medical expertise have historically failed to deliver meaningful reforms in the health sector.

KMPDU Deputy Secretary General Dennis Miskellah also expressed strong reservations about the appointment, arguing that the Health Ministry requires technical expertise, not political maneuvering.

He pointed out that past administrations had experimented with political appointments in the health docket, often with disappointing results. He referenced a recent minister who, despite criticism, had brought technical competence to the role.

Adding to the controversy, Duale recently made remarks that alarmed stakeholders in the private healthcare sector. He warned that the implementation of the new Social Health Authority (SHA) would lead to the closure of a significant number of private clinics, particularly those operating in residential areas.

His comments drew criticism from Miskellah, who argued that private health facilities are critical to the country’s healthcare system, serving over half of Kenya’s population.

Havi and KMPDU’s protests reflect a broader demand for the depoliticization of crucial government ministries. The sentiment is clear—Kenya’s healthcare sector is too vital to be subjected to political appointments that overlook professional qualifications.

As the debate continues, the big question is whether the government will change its mind about Duale’s appointment or ignore the protests. Only time will tell, but one thing is clear,more people are demanding qualified leaders in government.